Mirror, mirror on the wall, which Supernatural creature is the scariest of them all?

fans definitely remember those episodes that made you double-check your doors or maybe give that shady-looking mirror in your hallway the side-eye. We've all had those spine-tingling moments thanks to the show’s spine-chilling monsters.

With Halloween around the corner, it's the perfect time to remember those creepy creatures.

Shapeshifters are literally identity thieves. One minute you're having a good time with your bestie, and the next, they might be the creature trying to have you for dinner.

It’s the fear of not knowing if the person right next to you is actually who they say they are. The most terrifying part is seeing them change — when they shed their skin.

Maybe you tried the “say her name three times” game in front of the mirror at sleepovers, but Supernatural took this tale and spun it into a nerve-wracking yarn.

When the spirit of Mary Worthington, a woman who died staring into a mirror, with her scarred face and vindictive nature, comes for those who’ve spoken ill of the dead, she doesn't just spook — she delivers retribution.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.