had a strong 15-season run and even multiple spinoffs, so it would be unsurprising if it was given a modern reboot that recast the main characters. First airing in 2005, focused on the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean (played by Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles), as they followed in their father's footsteps to fight demons and eliminate dark supernatural entities from the Earth. The Winchester brothers’ relationship was a key aspect of

and, despite their best efforts, they often struggled to stay as close as when they were young.

was as recent as 2020, but it's more and more common for popular TV shows to be rebooted quickly after the original concluded. One example of this is the reboot, which although poorly received and quickly canceled created a story that was aimed at Gen Z. The prequel series was canceled in 2023 after only one season, so that may be it for the franchise.

If does want to continue with more stories, though, rebooting the original show with a new cast may be the most successful venture.

10 Benjamin Wadsworth As Sam

Benjamin Wadsworth is familiar with supernatural TV shows, as he previously appeared in and , but he is best known for starring in

. In the show, Wadsworth plays Marcus, a teenager who struggles to fit into Deadly Arts, a school for the deadliest characters in the world. Through his role as Marcus, Wadsworth has plenty of experience dealing with dark supernatural themes and playing characters trying to improve the world — not without a few rule breaks — so he would be a great fit for Sam Winchester in a reboot.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.